Back in 2010, veteran professional baseball outfielder Gary Matthews Jr. doled out $3 million for a vacant lot in the coveted Corona del Mar neighborhood of Orange County’s Newport Beach, about an hour south of Los Angeles.
The retired MLB star, who played with the L.A. Angels for three seasons from 2007 to 2009, went on to enlist architect Carlton Graham and builders Steve Davidson Construction and Tom Waters to create a two-story house completed in 2014. Now, after trying his hand at selling the place a few times before, he’s tossed the residence back on the market for just under $22 million, with Casey Lesher and Mondana Matthews of Christie’s International Real Estate, Southern California, holding the listing.

An upper-level living and dining area is off a view balcony spanning the entire length of the house.
Brett Hillyard
Perched on a blufftop parcel spanning a third of an acre in the desirable Irvine Terrace enclave on the ocean side of Coast Highway, the modern stone-accented structure offers four en suite bedrooms, five full bathrooms, and a pair of powder rooms in roughly 6,200 square feet imbued with a relaxed, California Coastal aesthetic. Two bright, airy levels showcase limestone floors and white oak ceilings, plus front-row views of the Newport Harbor, Balboa and Catalina islands, and the Pacific Ocean.
A large glass door off a private courtyard pivots into an upper-level entry foyer, which leads to a spacious great room anchored by a living area sporting a linear fireplace, a dining area, and a kitchen outfitted with premium stainless appliances and a gray waterfall island with seating for three. Also on this floor is a fireside primary suite highlighted by a sleek bath with dual vanities, a freestanding oval soaking tub, and indoor-outdoor showers.

A lounge and media room opens to a terraced backyard with an infinity-edge pool.
Brett Hillyard
RELATED: A Retired MLB Pitcher Just Listed His 2.5-Acre SoCal Estate for $23 Million
-
Featured Listing
Paris, Île-de-France 75002, France
Paris, France
$21,201,400 USD | 18,000,000 EUR -
Featured Listing
4867 Legacy Way, Park City, Utah 84060
Park City, UT
$22,000,000 USD -
Featured Listing
The Westerly Estate: A Tuscan Villa in Paradise
Santa Ynez, CA
$52,500,000 USD -
Featured Listing
161 Stillwater Rd, Aspen, CO 81611
Aspen, CO
$300,000,000 USD -
Featured Listing
111 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019
New York, NY
$98,000,000 USD
Rounding it all off is the lower level, which has a lounge and media room equipped with a seated wet bar and accordion-style doors opening to a terraced backyard hosting an infinity-edge pool, a raised spa, and a barbecue station. There’s also a glass-encased office lined with built-in shelves, as well as a climate-controlled wine cellar housing a full-size beverage refrigerator.
Matthews, 51, is the son of former Major Leaguer turned broadcaster Gary Matthews Sr. Now a real estate investor, the younger Matthews played professionally from 1999 to 2010, launching his career with the San Diego Padres and going on to play for the Chicago Cubs, Pittsburgh Pirates, Baltimore Orioles, Texas Rangers, L.A. Angels of Anaheim, and New York Mets.
Click here for more photos of the Orange County residence.
Authors
-
Wendy Bowman
Wendy Bowman is a real estate writer at Robb Report. Before that, she was a freelancer for Modern Luxury and several other media outlets, where she primarily covered luxury properties for…



